By Dave Slater, Natural England’s Director for wildlife licensing cases.
Breeding hen harriers in England are at a critical population level. Natural England is involved in a number of initiatives to help ensure hen harriers recover including Defra’s Hen Harrier Recovery Plan.
One of these initiatives is the hen harrier brood management trial. The aims of the brood management trial are to understand if it is possible to rear hen harriers in captivity and then release them to become successful breeding adults in the English uplands but also to investigate the effects of this technique on the perceptions and behaviour of the moorland community.
Natural England is also involved in monitoring surveys, protecting hen harriers from persecution and exploring re-introduction into the South of England.
Brood management involves the removal of hen harrier eggs and/or chicks to a dedicated hatching and rearing facility, where they are hand-reared in captivity, before being transferred to specially-constructed pens in hen harrier breeding habitat, from which they are then re-introduced into the wild in the uplands of northern England.
We issued the first 2 year trial licence in 2018. Earlier this year we received an application to renew this licence for a further two years. A renewal licence application has now been processed and we issued the licence on 20th May 2020.
Successful brood management intervention took place in 2019. All five chicks from the intervention nest were successfully raised to become healthy fledglings and released. That is a strong success rate compared to the 2018 nesting data which show that five of the 14 wild nests failed entirely and only two of the 14 wild nests were able to fledge five chicks.
We understand that some people may have questions and concerns over the taking of birds from the wild and so I wanted to outline more about this decision.
Evidence suggests that hand-rearing hen harriers in captivity before releasing them into the wild can lead to an improvement in their numbers and therefore their conservation status. Brood management is the sixth action within the Defra Hen Harrier Recovery Plan. One of the success criteria of the plan is to build confidence with land managers that thriving harrier populations can coexist with local business interests and contribute to a thriving rural economy.
This intervention may only occur in areas where there are already enough hen harrier nests to protect their numbers in the local population. The ‘trigger’ for brood management to commence is two successful nests occurring within 10km of each other, on a grouse moor.
The licence is time-limited for a 2-year period and places stringent conditions on the trial. We have rigorously scrutinised the licence application and will work closely with the licence applicant throughout the duration of the trial to ensure that all elements are carried out proportionately and effectively, to bring about the best possible outcome for hen harriers.
The applicant will have to provide evidence that they have taken every precaution to ensure the welfare of the birds or local populations are not affected.
We understand that there are active hen harrier nests this year that meet the licensed criteria for trial brood management and willing landowners who want to be part of the trial.
We will shortly publish the redacted licence and a link will be provided here.
Update July 2020
Numbers of successful nests in England continue to rise over recent years since the launch of the Defra Recovery Plan in 2016. Numbers are still well below where they could be, but there have been over 20 successful nests recorded in England so far this year.
We have been working hard with the Brood Management licensees over the last two months to ensure the brood management trial went well and licence conditions were adhered to.
Earlier this month, eight of the juveniles were released. We were sad to hear that one of the nine chicks in the trial died shortly prior to release. We are currently working with the project team to establish cause of death, and we will provide a further update when cause has been established.
Comment by Pete Etheridge posted on
Were the five chicks that were released in 2019 fitted with satellite tags? Do you have any information regarding their status (i.e. alive or dead/missing)?
Comment by Chris Keeling posted on
I question the concept of managing a nearly extinct species in favour of a species hunted for recreation, knowing that the argument in favour of the whole package of grouse management and limiting hen harrier populations will be informed and driven by the economic argument. Perhaps hunters could be persuaded to shoot fewer grouse. Fewer grouse for shooters? Come to think of it there are damn few hen harriers, are we saying that hen harriers shouldn't be permitted to nest or hunt on moorlands. NE has set itself an unfortunate precedence sending a message of justification to recreational hunters and fishermen that fewer predators means more quarry species. What next, fewer otters, and ospreys more fish for anglers?
Comment by Francis Morgan posted on
Pete - not sure why NE haven't bothered to answer your question, but all 5 of the brood managed birds are missing. 4 of the disappearances are potentially suspicious:
maybe its because they don't like the answer.
Comment by A Walker posted on
What happened to your undertaking not to issue a licence in the face of ongoing persecution?
It seems that your enthusiasm for issuing this licence is out of step with your duty to conserve the species and ensure that the law is upheld.
Comment by Robert Bonner posted on
What evidence have you in regard to the success of the last experiment. One would have thought that there must be some positive evidence for the licence to be renewed.
Comment by Chris Keeling posted on
question knowing that the argument in favour of the whole package of grouse management and limiting hen harrier populations will be informed and driven by the economic argument. Perhaps hunters could be persuaded to shoot fewer grouse. Fewer grouse for shooters? Come to think of it there are damn few hen harriers, are we saying that hen harriers shouldn't be permitted to nest or hunt on moorlands
Comment by A Walker posted on
"Evidence suggests that hand-rearing hen harriers in captivity before releasing them into the wild can lead to an improvement in their numbers and therefore their conservation status. "
If you take five chicks, hand rear them, then release them into the wild, you still only have five chicks. There is no increase in numbers.
If you mean increase in numbers surviving, all you have to do is stop the land owners and game keepers killing the birds. They kill the birds you release any way. Your project is a pointless waste of money.